Argumentative Paper

Audience
For this paper, I want you to imagine you are writing an opinion piece for a national, academic magazine. But be forewarned, this magazine rejects articles that aren’t grounded in a careful, well reasoned analysis of the differing sides of an issue.

Your complete draft must include
A 1-2 page introduction establishing a context for your argument.

A body that reports on, analyzes, and evaluates the positions of the sources you’ve cited; remember, you must include counter-arguments in the section.

A conclusion: for example, a call to action, a restatement of your thesis, or a statement of implication.

It must also have a spiffy and engaging title.

A Works Cited Page.

Remember that a good argument will
Offer reasons and evidence

Critically examine the assumptions on which your own position is based

Consider objectively and think through opposing arguments

Anticipate objections

Ask yourself these questions to determine the best way to persuade your audience
Can I base my argument on changing the definition of the topic? Can I say, “while most people think X is Y, I propose that X is better thought of as Z.”

Can I focus on relative value? “While there are many breeds of dogs available for purchase, the American Eskimo makes a better family pet than a Chihuahua.”

Can I do a compare/contrast? “Higher education in the United states ought to be free for students who qualify because Britain offers free education for qualifying students and we have to maintain a competitive edge.”

Can you argue from consequence? “Decriminalizing marijuana and taxing its sale and distribution will result in increased revenue.”

Consider using these materials for this assignment
Effective Titles and Introductions PPT

Writing a Thesis with Pooh

What is a Thesis Slideshow

Integrating Sources

Research Proposal Assignment Rhetorical Proof Cards

Brainstorming for Research Topics

Brainstorming Title and Introduction Ideas

Claims and Reasons Game